PART 2: The Song Only Elena Knew11 026
Part 2 – The Song Only Elena Knew
Lily’s small hand rested against my chest, and for a moment I could only stare at her.
“Daddy,” she repeated, quieter this time, as if testing the word for its shape.
My daughters had spoken three words in less than a minute, and every one of them had reached into a place inside me I had believed sealed shut.
Hannah watched me, her eyes bright with tears.
The guards remained still around us, their attention shifting between my face and the woman my children had called Mama.
“Let’s get everyone somewhere safe,” I said, though my voice sounded less like an order than a plea.
Hannah straightened, keeping one arm around Emma.
“Safe from whom?”
“I don’t know yet.”
“Then you don’t get to decide that I’m going with you.”
The answer was reasonable, and I hated that the men behind me seemed to regard it as defiance.
I turned toward them.
“Stand down.”
They lowered their hands, but none of them moved away.
Hannah glanced at the restaurant’s shattered glasses, the staring customers, and the little girls clinging to her.
“I’ll come because they’re frightened,” she said. “Not because you ordered it.”
“I understand.”
She gave me a searching look, apparently waiting for me to challenge her.
When I didn’t, she gathered her purse and coat while I asked the restaurant manager to arrange for the broken glass to be cleared.
The rain had eased by the time we stepped outside, leaving the street slick with reflections from the traffic lights.
A black car waited at the curb.
Hannah hesitated when she saw the two security vehicles behind it.
“You said safe,” she murmured. “You didn’t say convoy.”
“I’ll have one car follow at a distance.”
“And no one is going to take my phone or tell me where I’m allowed to go?”
“No.”
The answer came too quickly, so I added, “You can leave whenever you want.”
Hannah looked down at Emma, who had wrapped both hands around the collar of her coat.
“I’m not leaving them while they’re this upset.”
“That’s your choice.”
It was the first time I had admitted aloud that she had one.
Inside the car, Lily and Grace sat in their familiar seats beside the nanny, Mrs. Alvarez, while Emma remained on Hannah’s lap.
The trip to the estate took twenty minutes.
I spent every one of them watching my daughters through the rearview mirror and trying not to look too long at the woman holding one of them.
Hannah kept her gaze on the rain-streaked window.
Once, when we passed a florist, she leaned forward as if something in the shop had caught her attention, but she said nothing.
At the estate gates, the security lights washed the car in pale gold.
Hannah stiffened when the iron gates opened.
“Do you always live behind a wall?” she asked.
“Most days, it feels less like a wall and more like a habit.”
“That doesn’t answer the question.”
“No,” I said. “I suppose I do.”
The estate stood on several acres beyond the gates, an old stone house with warm lights in the windows and bare branches shifting in the wind.
I had chosen it for its distance from the city and the space it gave the girls.
At that moment, I saw it through Hannah’s eyes: beautiful, protected, and possibly impossible to leave without permission.
I turned to the driver.
“Bring the car to the front entrance, then take the security team back to the outer gate.”
Hannah looked at me, surprised.
“I meant what I said about your choice.”
The entrance opened before we reached it.
Mrs. Alvarez came out, her gray hair pinned neatly at the back of her head, her expression worried until she saw the girls.
“Mr. Vale, I heard they spoke.”
“They did,” I said.
She glanced at Hannah, then offered her a warm, careful smile.
“I’m Rosa Alvarez. I’ve been caring for these three since they came home from the hospital.”
“Hannah Mercer.”
The names seemed to pause between them.
Mrs. Alvarez’s gaze lingered on Hannah’s face, not with suspicion but with the puzzled attention of someone trying to place a familiar tune.
Then Emma began to fuss, and the moment passed.
The girls were tired, and the whole house seemed to move at their quiet, uncertain pace.
Rosa carried Lily’s coat upstairs while Grace held my hand.
Hannah walked beside Emma, who had refused to let go of her.
At the foot of the staircase, Grace stopped and looked up at me.
“Daddy,” she said.
The word came out rough and hesitant, but it was unmistakable.
I crouched in front of her.
“That’s right, sweetheart.”
She touched my cheek, then turned to Hannah.
“Mama.”
Hannah’s breath caught.
“I’m Hannah,” she whispered.
Grace studied her as if considering the difference.
Then she rested her head against Hannah’s shoulder.
I wanted to tell my daughter that the name might be wrong.
I wanted to tell myself the same thing.
Instead, I watched Hannah close her eyes for a heartbeat, accepting the small weight of Grace’s trust without trying to claim more than it offered.
I had a guest room prepared for her near the family rooms, with a lock on the inside of the door and another exit through the adjoining study.
Hannah noticed both doors.
“Which one am I supposed to use?”
“Whichever you prefer.”
“And if I want to leave?”
“I’ll have the driver take you wherever you ask.”
She searched my face for a hidden condition.
There wasn’t one, though I understood why she expected to find it.
After Rosa took the girls upstairs to change, Hannah stayed in the hallway with me.
“You said your wife died when the girls were born,” she said.
“Yes.”
“Then why did you look at me as if you had seen a ghost?”
“Because of the scar, the photograph, and the records.”
“That still doesn’t explain why you keep looking at me.”
I tried to answer honestly.
“Because my wife had your eyes.”
Hannah’s expression tightened.
“I’m sorry.”
“So am I.”
We stood in the quiet hall, surrounded by family portraits that made the house feel full of people who were no longer there.
Hannah looked at one photograph: Elena and me on the coast, laughing into the wind.
“Was she happy?”
The question unsettled me more than any accusation could have.
“I thought she was.”
“Thought?”
“I was away too often. I made choices for the family without asking whether anyone wanted them.”
I had spent years calling that protection.
Hannah seemed to hear the part I had left unsaid.
“Did she know you loved her?”
“I told her.”
“That isn’t the same as making someone feel loved.”
“No,” I said. “It isn’t.”
The answer surprised her.
Maybe it surprised me, too.
She looked again at Elena’s photograph.
“I don’t remember anything from before I was eight,” she said. “Not names or places or a face I can be certain of. My father told me I had an accident when I was little.”
“Your father is Michael Mercer?”
“Yes.”
“You’ve lived with him since the accident?”
“Not exactly. I grew up with him, but there were years when I lived with other relatives. I was told my mother died when I was very young.”
“Do you remember her?”
Hannah shook her head.
“Sometimes I dream about a woman singing. I always wake before I can see her face.”
My attention sharpened.
“What does she sing?”
“I don’t know. I can never remember the tune in the morning.”
For the first time since the restaurant, she looked genuinely unsettled.
“What about the accident?”
“I have medical papers from when I was young, but they’re incomplete. My father said he couldn’t get some of the records. The story was always the same: head injury, weeks unconscious, and then a new beginning.”
“Did you ask questions?”
“Of course.”
“And?”
“He told me that too much was lost to recover, and that I should be grateful to have survived.”
She said it without bitterness, but it sounded like a sentence she had repeated to herself for years.
I knew something about living with missing pieces.
After the shooting, I had spent months waking from dreams of a hospital room, certain I had heard Elena’s voice, only to be told that grief had given my mind the sound it wanted.
When I asked who had signed her death certificate, I was told the paperwork was complete.
When I asked whether I could see her, I was told her body had been too damaged for an open viewing.
I had accepted the explanation because I was barely conscious and because Victor had been there.
Victor had been there through every difficult hour of my recovery.
I had trusted him.
“I’m going to look into the records,” I said.
Hannah’s shoulders went rigid.
“Without asking me?”
“I meant the hospital records connected to Elena.”
“You’re going to investigate my life whether I agree or not.”
“I’m trying to understand what happened.”
“So am I.” Her voice stayed low, but it carried more pain than anger. “I’ve spent half my life being told that questions won’t help. I won’t have someone else decide what I’m allowed to know.”
“I won’t take anything from you.”
“You already summoned a security team because my face reminded you of your dead wife.”
“I’m sorry.”
The apology sat between us.
It did not erase the fear in her eyes, but it seemed to surprise her more than an argument would have.
Before either of us could speak again, Rosa appeared at the top of the stairs.
“The girls are ready for bed,” she called. “But they want Hannah.”
Hannah glanced at me.
“You can say no,” I told her.
“I know.”
She followed Rosa upstairs.
I stayed in the hallway, hearing the soft murmur of voices beyond the nursery door.
It was the first time in two years I had not been the person my daughters needed most.
It should have hurt.
Instead, I felt grateful that they wanted someone.
The nursery was painted a pale blue, with three small beds and a wide window overlooking the garden.
Lily sat beneath a blanket while Rosa brushed out her hair.
Grace was already in bed, watching Hannah as though afraid she might disappear.
Emma sat on Hannah’s lap.
“Do they usually have trouble sleeping?” Hannah asked.
“Some nights,” Rosa said. “They’re good children, but quiet children can still have a lot to say.”
Hannah’s expression softened.
She leaned over and kissed Emma’s forehead, then stopped abruptly, as if she had surprised herself.
Emma only snuggled closer.
I stood in the doorway, unsure whether I belonged in that room.
Lily saw me and patted the mattress beside her.
“Daddy.”
The word was still new enough to hurt.
I sat down, and she reached for my hand.
Hannah began to hum.
It was soft at first, almost a breath with notes hidden inside it.
The girls’ eyes grew heavy.
Rosa stopped brushing Lily’s hair.
I knew the melody.
Not from the radio or a lullaby played in the nursery.
I knew it from the old family video I had watched so many times after Elena died that I could recall the grainy light on the walls.
In the video, Elena sat on the floor between two empty bassinets, her hands resting over the curve of her pregnancy.
She had looked into the camera and said, “This one is for the girls. I don’t want anyone else teaching it to them.”
Then she had sung a tune without a name.
I had never heard it anywhere else.
Hannah’s voice faltered on the last phrase.
Her eyes opened, and she looked at me.
“Where did you learn that song?” I asked.
She went still.
“I don’t know.”
“That tune—it belonged to Elena.”
Hannah shook her head, as if denying it might make the room settle back into something ordinary.
“I’ve never met your wife.”
“I know.”
“Then I don’t understand.”
Neither did I.
Grace reached for Hannah’s fingers, and Hannah took them carefully.
“Maybe I heard it somewhere,” she whispered.
“No,” I said, before I could stop myself. “It was never public.”
The words sounded like an accusation, and I regretted them at once.
Hannah’s face closed.
“I told you I don’t remember my childhood.”
“I’m not accusing you.”
“You’re looking at me like you’ve already decided who I am.”
I turned away from her.
For years I had thought there were only two possibilities: Elena had died, or someone had lied about her death.
Now a third possibility had entered the room, one with Hannah’s face and a song that should have belonged to no one else.
Rosa tucked the blankets around the girls.
Hannah stood, leaving them asleep with her warmth still in the room.
In the hallway, she folded her arms over her chest.
“I’m staying tonight for them,” she said. “Tomorrow, I want to talk to my father.”
“I’ll arrange it.”
“And I want to see every record you have about Elena.”
“You will.”
“No one should keep making decisions around me while I’m standing right here.”
“You’re right.”
She studied me, searching for the man who had ordered a restaurant secured and an entire household put on alert.
Perhaps she still saw him.
Perhaps I did, too.
I walked with her to the guest room, then stopped outside its open door.
“If you need anything, Rosa is across the hall.”
“I can take care of myself.”
“I know.”
Hannah entered the room.
Before she closed the door, she looked back at me.
“Do you think I’m your wife?”
“I don’t know what I think.”
“That’s not an answer.”
“It’s the only honest one I have.”
She watched me for another moment, then shut the door gently.
I returned to my study and opened the secure archive where I kept the video of Elena.
The file began with a date from six months before the girls were born.
Elena appeared in the frame, smiling at me from a patch of afternoon sunlight.
I had watched the recording countless times, but never with anyone else singing the melody.
I played the section again.
There was Elena’s voice, warm and low, and the same rising notes Hannah had hummed in the nursery.
“This one is for the girls,” Elena said on the recording. “I don’t want anyone else teaching it to them.”
Then she sang the tune once more.
I froze the frame and opened the hospital file.
The death record had been signed by Victor Hale, my security chief and the man who had managed my affairs while I recovered from the shooting.
I called him.
He answered on the second ring.
“Dominic,” he said. “Are the girls all right?”
“They’re asleep.”
“And the waitress?”
“She’s here.”
A brief silence followed.
“Here where?”
“At the estate.”
“Why?”
“Because my daughters called her Mama.”
Victor breathed out slowly.
“You can’t let that frighten you into believing something without proof.”
“I’m not.”
“Good. A stranger’s resemblance and a child’s confusion aren’t proof.”
“I know.”
“Let me come over in the morning,” he said. “We can review the old files together.”
I looked at the paused image of Elena.
“Tomorrow.”
After the call ended, I pulled the birth records from the archive and opened the oldest scanned photograph of the hospital corridor.
It showed a nurse pushing a wheelchair beneath a row of fluorescent lights.
The woman in the chair faced away from the camera.
Her right hand rested on the armrest, pale against the dark fabric.
Around her wrist was a narrow bracelet with a small silver charm.
I had given Elena that bracelet on our first anniversary.
The file had always been labeled as an unrelated security image.
I enlarged the photograph until the pixels blurred.
Then I heard a soft sound behind me.
Hannah stood in the study doorway.
She had not been able to sleep.
Her eyes moved from the frozen image to the bracelet on the screen, and the color drained from her face.
“I’ve seen that before,” she whispered.
“Where?”
“I don’t know.”
She stepped closer, touching the empty skin around her own wrist.
Then she began humming the lullaby again, this time without looking at the screen.
The melody was exactly the same.
And when she reached the final note, she said a name she had never heard me speak.
“Elena.”
**–END OF PART 2–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
* * *
[NEXT: PART 3](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-3-the-song-only-elena-knew11-026)
✓ S. Gary Kenneth
Part 2 – The Song Only Elena Knew Lily’s small hand rested against my chest, and for a moment I could only stare at her. “Daddy,” she repeated, quieter this time, as if testing the word for its shap…