Part 2 – The Things We Choose-068
## Part 2 – The Envelope on the Counter
**Part 2**
The date beneath Carter’s name was three weeks old.
For several seconds, that was the only fact my mind seemed capable of processing.
Three weeks.
Three weeks before Logan and I had walked into the tattoo studio laughing.
Three weeks before I had held out my wrist while a stranger permanently etched three letters into my skin.
Three weeks before I had come home expecting another argument I could win.
I looked at Carter.
“What is this?”
“Open it.”
His voice wasn’t cold.
Coldness would have been easier.
Coldness would have given me something to fight.
Instead, he sounded tired.
I slid one finger beneath the flap.
Inside was a thick stack of papers.
The first page bore the name of a law firm.
The second had my name.
And Carter’s.
I stopped breathing for a moment.
“Divorce?”
The word sounded absurd in our kitchen.
This was the same kitchen where Carter made pancakes every Sunday morning because I always burned the first batch.
The same kitchen where we had opened champagne after closing on the townhouse.
The same kitchen where, only four months earlier, he had stood behind me while I stirred pasta sauce and rested his chin on my shoulder.
Divorce did not belong here.
But there it was.
Black ink.
White paper.
My husband’s signature.
Dated three weeks ago.
“You filed?”
“No.”
I looked up.
Carter had moved to the other side of the island.
“I spoke to an attorney,” he said. “Those are draft separation papers.”
“You were planning to leave me?”
“I was deciding whether there was anything left to stay for.”
The words landed more softly than they should have.
That made them worse.
My phone vibrated again.
I didn’t turn it over.
Carter’s eyes dropped briefly toward it.
“That’s a first.”
“What?”
“You ignored him.”
A strange heat rose into my face.
“Don’t do that.”
“Do what?”
“Make everything about Logan.”
Carter gave the smallest nod.
“That’s the problem, Erin. I don’t have to.”
I hated the calmness in his voice.
It made me feel like I was arriving late to a conversation he’d been having alone for months.
I pushed the papers away.
“So this was some kind of test?”
“No.”
“You had divorce papers hidden in our kitchen, and you were waiting to see what I did?”
“They’re not divorce papers. They’re a proposed separation agreement.”
“That distinction doesn’t exactly make me feel better.”
“It wasn’t supposed to.”
I stared at him.
He rubbed his thumb against the pale band of skin where his wedding ring had been.
“I made an appointment with the attorney after your birthday.”
My birthday had been twenty-six days earlier.
I remembered dinner at a small Italian restaurant in Cherry Creek.
Carter had reserved the table by the window because I liked seeing the lights along the street.
He had given me a necklace.
Logan had texted halfway through dessert.
A joke about something that had happened when we were twenty-five.
I had laughed so hard I nearly spilled my wine.
Carter had asked what was funny.
I had said, “You wouldn’t get it.”
The memory made my stomach turn.
“After my birthday?” I whispered.
“Yes.”
“Why?”
He studied me for a moment.
“Do you really not know?”
I wanted to say no.
Instead, I remembered the expression on his face that night.
I hadn’t thought much of it.
That realization hurt in a way I hadn’t expected.
Carter continued.
“We were sitting there together, and you spent half the meal checking your phone.”
“That isn’t true.”
“You checked it eleven times.”
I almost laughed.
Not because it was funny.
Because the number sounded so precise.
“You counted?”
“No. I remember.”
I folded my arms.
“Logan was trying to organize something for me.”
“He was sending you pictures from your trip to Mexico.”
My heart stumbled.
Carter knew.
Of course he knew.
The trip had happened six years before Carter and I met.
Logan and I had gone to Cancún with three friends.
At the time, Logan and I were still sleeping together.
Nothing Carter hadn’t known.
Nothing secret.
At least that was what I had always told myself.
“That was ancient history.”
“I know.”
“Then why did it matter?”
“Because my wife spent her birthday dinner with me laughing at photographs of herself in bed with another man.”
My mouth opened.
I closed it again.
The picture had not actually shown us in bed.
Not exactly.
Logan had been lying under a hotel sheet, making a ridiculous face while I leaned into the frame beside him.
It was stupid.
Immature.
Old.
And when Carter had glanced over that evening, I had tilted the phone away.
I remembered that too.
“You could have said something.”
“I did.”
“No, you didn’t.”
“Yes, Erin. I did.”
He said it quietly.
“You told me I was being insecure.”
My eyes dropped to the papers.
I could hear the refrigerator humming.
Outside, tires hissed over wet pavement.
Denver had been drizzling since late afternoon, a thin November rain that made the windows look blurred.
“I didn’t realize you were this unhappy.”
“That might be the hardest thing you’ve said tonight.”
I looked at him.
His eyes were red now, although he hadn’t cried.
Not yet.
“Why?”
“Because I’ve been telling you.”
I pressed my fingertips against the edge of the island.
Carter walked toward the living room window.
For a moment, he stood with his back to me.
“I asked you to stop answering his calls in bed.”
I remembered.
“I asked whether the two of you could stop making sexual jokes when I’m sitting next to you.”
I remembered that too.
“I asked if you could spend one weekend with me without inviting him.”
My throat tightened.
“I asked why he had a key to our house.”
“That was for emergencies.”
“He used it to let himself in and eat leftovers.”
“He was joking.”
“I know.”
Something in those two words finally broke through my defenses.
He was joking.
That had been my answer to everything.
Logan was joking.
I was joking.
The tattoo was funny.
The late-night texts were harmless.
The old pictures were history.
The private language was friendship.
Any discomfort Carter felt was insecurity.
Any objection was control.
Any boundary was an attempt to dictate my life.
I had built an explanation for everything.
And somehow, inside those explanations, my husband had disappeared.
“I never cheated on you,” I said.
Carter turned around.
“I believe you.”
His answer surprised me so much I couldn’t speak.
“I have never believed you were physically unfaithful,” he continued. “That was never what this was about.”
“Then what is it about?”
“Priority.”
My eyes burned.
“You’re my husband.”
“On paper.”
“That’s not fair.”
“No. It isn’t.”
For the first time that night, his voice cracked.
He looked away.
“I kept waiting for there to be a moment when you would choose our marriage without me having to force you.”
“You never asked me to choose.”
“Exactly.”
I shook my head.
“That doesn’t make sense.”
“It makes perfect sense. I didn’t want to be the man who told his wife she wasn’t allowed to have a friend. I wanted to be married to someone who cared when something hurt me.”
“I do care.”
“You care now.”
That stopped me.
He wasn’t cruel when he said it.
There was no triumph in his expression.
Only grief.
My phone vibrated again.
Neither of us looked at it.
I swallowed.
“What happened three weeks ago?”
Carter exhaled slowly.
“I came home early.”
My fingers went cold.
“When?”
“The Thursday you and Logan watched the Broncos game.”
I remembered that evening.
Carter had been in Colorado Springs for work.
Or so I thought.
Logan had brought pizza.
We had watched the game.
We had consumed too much wine.
Nothing happened.
I knew nothing happened.
“What did you see?”
“I didn’t see anything.”
“Then—”
“I heard you.”
My chest tightened.
Carter walked back to the island.
“You were on the patio.”
I tried to remember.
The game.
The pizza.
The wine.
Logan making fun of Carter’s expensive coffee grinder.
Me defending it.
Or had I?
“What did you hear?”
Carter looked directly at me.
“Logan asked whether I had finally stopped complaining about him.”
My stomach sank.
Fragments returned.
Logan laughing.
Me rolling my eyes.
The city lights beyond our patio railing.
“And you said,” Carter continued, “‘Carter knows better than to make me choose. He’d lose.’”
The room became very still.
I remembered.
Not immediately.
Then completely.
Logan had laughed.
I had laughed too.
I had been tipsy.
I hadn’t meant—
The excuses rose automatically.
I swallowed them.
Carter nodded, as though he could see them gathering behind my teeth.
“I stood in the hallway for maybe thirty seconds.”
“Carter…”
“And then Logan said something else.”
I suddenly didn’t want to know.
“What?”
“He said, ‘Poor guy married into a relationship he can never compete with.’”
My skin prickled.
I remembered Logan saying that.
At the time, it had sounded like another joke.
“What did I say?”
Carter stared at me.
I knew before he answered that whatever came next would hurt.
“You said, ‘Not my problem.’”
I shut my eyes.
The memory was there.
Clear.
Awful.
Not my problem.
Three careless words spoken over a glass of wine.
Except they hadn’t been careless to the man standing inside the hallway.
“I didn’t mean it like that.”
“I know.”
I opened my eyes.
“You keep saying that.”
“Because I believe you.”
His expression softened, and somehow that was unbearable.
“I don’t think you wanted to hurt me, Erin. I think it was worse than that.”
“What could be worse?”
“You didn’t think about me at all.”
Silence spread between us.
My phone buzzed for what felt like the hundredth time.
This time Carter reached for his suitcase.
“Where are you going?”
“My brother’s.”
“For how long?”
“I don’t know.”
Fear surged through me.
“No.”
He paused.
I came around the island.
“Carter, no. We can’t just end our marriage like this.”
“I’m not ending it tonight.”
“You took off your ring.”
“Because right now, wearing it feels dishonest.”
My throat tightened.
“What am I supposed to do?”
For the first time, something resembling anger flashed across his face.
“I don’t know, Erin.”
Then it disappeared.
“That is part of the problem. I’ve spent months telling you what I need, and you kept demanding that I prove I had a right to need it.”
I looked down at my wrist.
FWB Forever.
The skin around the letters was still pink.
Less than two hours old.
For the first time, the tattoo didn’t look rebellious.
It looked childish.
“What if I remove it?”
Carter’s expression changed.
Not hope.
Something sadder.
“Do you want to?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because it hurt you.”
He nodded slowly.
“And if I hadn’t packed my bags?”
I couldn’t answer.
That answer told him enough.
He lifted his suitcase.
“Please don’t go.”
His shoulders stiffened.
I stepped closer, but stopped before touching him.
“I know that sounds selfish.”
“It does.”
“I don’t know what I’m supposed to say.”
“Maybe that’s okay.”
“How can that be okay?”
“Because for once you aren’t telling me why I’m wrong to feel what I feel.”
He walked toward the front door.
Panic rose in my chest.
“Carter.”
He looked back.
“I love you.”
His eyes closed for one brief second.
“I love you too.”
Hope flared.
Then he said, “Love hasn’t been the problem.”
The door opened.
Cold air entered the townhouse.
He left.
I stood there listening to the wheels of his suitcase bump over the threshold.
Then the door shut.
I didn’t move for several minutes.
Eventually, I returned to the kitchen.
The separation agreement remained on the island.
Beside it sat Carter’s wedding ring.
My phone.
And the photograph Logan had sent.
Forever means forever.
I picked up the phone.
There were seven messages.
LOGAN: He freak out yet?
LOGAN: 😂
LOGAN: You alive?
LOGAN: Erin?
LOGAN: Don’t tell me Captain Sensitive is sulking again.
LOGAN: Call me.
Then the last message.
LOGAN: I told you he’d eventually make you choose.
I stared at it.
My fingers trembled.
Something about the sentence bothered me.
Not just the contempt.
Not just the assumption.
The wording.
Eventually.
As though Logan had been waiting for this.
I typed:
Why would you say that?
The three dots appeared almost immediately.
Then vanished.
Appeared again.
LOGAN: Because I know him.
I frowned.
No, he didn’t.
Carter and Logan had never spent time alone together.
They tolerated one another at birthdays and group dinners.
Nothing more.
I typed:
You barely know Carter.
This time the reply took nearly a minute.
LOGAN: More than you think.
I stared at the screen.
Before I could respond, another message appeared.
LOGAN: Ask him what happened at Union Station last month.
I stopped breathing.
Last month?
Carter had been at Union Station for a client meeting.
At least, that was what he’d told me.
I immediately called him.
Straight to voicemail.
I called again.
Voicemail.
Then Logan sent one final message.
LOGAN: He never told you we met, did he?
And for the first time that night, the story I thought I understood changed completely.
**–END OF PART 2–CLICK “”NEXT”” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
✓ S. Gary Kenneth
## Part 2 – The Envelope on the Counter **Part 2** The date beneath Carter’s name was three weeks old. For several seconds, that was the only fact my mind seemed capable of processing. Three weeks…