✓ LifeofMyStory

Part 4 – The Things We Choose-068

Posted by S. Gary Kenneth - November 20, 2026

## Part 4 – The Version I Was Given

**Part 4**

Natalie agreed to meet me the following afternoon.

We chose a small café near Washington Park.

Neutral ground.

Public.

Quiet.

I arrived fifteen minutes early and spent fourteen of those minutes considering leaving.

Everything about the meeting felt disloyal.

That was the first thing that frightened me.

Not disloyal to Carter.

Disloyal to Logan.

Even after everything I’d learned, some invisible rule inside me insisted that speaking to someone Logan disliked was a betrayal.

I began wondering how many of those rules existed.

Natalie arrived exactly on time.

She was not what I expected.

For years, Logan had described her as intense.

Dramatic.

Possessive.

The woman who couldn’t tolerate the idea that he had female friends.

The woman who “went crazy” whenever my name appeared on his phone.

I had pictured someone sharp-edged and restless.

Instead, Natalie was quiet.

She wore a gray sweater, dark jeans, and no visible makeup beyond mascara.

She sat across from me and wrapped both hands around a mug of tea.

“Thank you for coming.”

“Why did you contact me?”

She took a slow breath.

“Because Logan called me.”

“Three weeks ago?”

“Yes.”

“What did he want?”

“He asked me what I remembered about our breakup.”

I frowned.

“That doesn’t make sense.”

“It didn’t to me either.”

“Did he explain why?”

“He said you were having problems with Carter.”

My stomach tightened.

“How would he know three weeks ago?”

Natalie gave me a look I couldn’t interpret.

“Erin, I think Logan has known you were having problems for a long time.”

I wanted to defend him.

I could feel the impulse rising.

“He’s my best friend. Of course he knew.”

“Did Carter know everything Logan knew?”

The question silenced me.

Natalie noticed my wrist.

I had covered the tattoo with a bandage.

She glanced at it, then back at my face.

“I saw the picture.”

“What picture?”

“Logan sent it to me.”

I froze.

“When?”

“The night you got the tattoos.”

My pulse accelerated.

“Why?”

“I think he wanted a reaction.”

“What did you say?”

“Nothing.”

“Nothing?”

“I blocked him.”

A strange mixture of shame and anger rose inside me.

I had believed the photograph was ours.

Some private symbol of defiance.

Apparently Logan had immediately distributed it to someone he hadn’t spoken to in years.

“Why did he call you three weeks ago?”

Natalie stirred her tea though she hadn’t added anything to it.

“He asked whether I thought we would still be together if you hadn’t been in his life.”

I stared at her.

“What did you say?”

“No.”

The answer came without hesitation.

Not because of certainty.

Because she had clearly considered it many times before.

“I told him we broke up because he didn’t respect boundaries.”

“Did you ask him to stop seeing me?”

“No.”

“But he told me—”

“I know what he told you.”

Her expression wasn’t angry.

That made it harder.

“He told me you demanded he choose.”

“I did ask him to choose eventually.”

I stiffened.

Natalie held up one hand.

“After ten months of asking for basic privacy. After he read you messages I’d sent him during arguments. After he told you things about my family I’d asked him not to share. After he invited you to a weekend trip we had planned for our anniversary.”

I remembered that trip.

Aspen.

Logan had told me Natalie canceled because she was angry I might join them.

What he had never told me was that it had been their anniversary.

“I didn’t know.”

“I assumed you didn’t.”

“Why?”

“Because you actually apologized when I texted you once.”

I stared at her.

“You never texted me.”

“Yes, I did.”

“No.”

She pulled out her phone.

After a few taps, she slid it toward me.

There it was.

A message sent four years earlier.

Natalie: Hi, Erin. I don’t think you know this was supposed to be our anniversary weekend. Logan said he invited you without telling me. I’m not angry with you, but I wanted you to know why I’m upset.

Below it was my reply.

Except I had never written it.

Me: Maybe if you weren’t so insecure, he’d want to spend weekends alone with you.

I felt sick.

“I didn’t send that.”

Natalie watched me.

“I figured.”

“How?”

“Because the writing didn’t sound like you.”

“You didn’t know me.”

“No. But I’d seen your messages because Logan showed them to me.”

Of course he had.

I looked again.

The date.

The time.

I tried to remember.

Then a memory surfaced.

Logan borrowing my phone during a concert because his battery had died.

He had known my passcode.

He still did, until six months ago.

“He sent that.”

“I believe so.”

I handed the phone back.

“Why didn’t you tell me?”

“I tried once.”

“When?”

“After we broke up.”

“I never got anything.”

“I sent you a long message on Instagram.”

“I would’ve seen it.”

“He had access to your account?”

I stopped.

Years earlier, Logan and I had logged into each other’s accounts as a joke while planning a group trip.

I had changed my password eventually.

Hadn’t I?

I suddenly wasn’t sure when.

Natalie looked down.

“This is why I contacted you.”

“What is?”

“Because I think Logan has spent a long time controlling the stories the people around him hear.”

The word controlling made me flinch.

I had thrown it at Carter so easily.

Now it sounded different.

“Why contact me now?”

“Because of what he said when he called.”

“What did he say?”

Natalie hesitated.

“He sounded excited.”

“About my marriage falling apart?”

“He didn’t say it that way.”

“What way did he say it?”

She met my eyes.

“He said, ‘I think Erin is finally going to realize she married the wrong person.’”

My fingers tightened around my coffee cup.

“And you thought that was strange?”

“I thought it was familiar.”

She told me about the end of their relationship.

Every time Natalie had tried to establish distance between herself and me, Logan told her she was forcing him to abandon his oldest friend.

Every time she protested that he was sharing intimate details, he accused her of jealousy.

Whenever she became angry, he reported the anger to me without telling me what had caused it.

I remembered those conversations.

Natalie yelled again.

Natalie checked my phone.

Natalie doesn’t want you around.

I had responded exactly as Logan wanted.

She’s insecure.

She needs to get over it.

Don’t let her control you.

The words I’d used against Natalie were nearly identical to the ones I’d later used against Carter.

Had they really been mine?

Or had Logan handed me a vocabulary I never questioned?

Natalie didn’t accuse him of being evil.

She didn’t say he had manipulated every moment.

That would have been easier to dismiss.

Instead she said something far more believable.

“I think Logan needs to be the most important person in certain people’s lives. I don’t even know if he realizes he’s doing it.”

I looked out the window.

A man was jogging past with a golden retriever.

Leaves skittered across the pavement.

Ordinary life continued outside.

Inside, years of my own history were rearranging themselves.

“Why me?” I asked.

Natalie frowned.

“Why does he need to be the most important person to me?”

“I can’t answer that.”

“Because we slept together?”

“Maybe.”

“We stopped years ago.”

“That doesn’t mean the relationship stopped serving some purpose for him.”

I hated the clinical sound of that.

“What purpose?”

Natalie was silent for a moment.

“Proof.”

“Of what?”

“That someone will always choose him.”

The words made my chest ache.

I thought of the tattoo.

Permanent.

Untouchable.

Forever.

Not friendship.

Proof.

My phone remained silent because Logan was still blocked.

For the first time since we’d met at twenty-one, he had no immediate access to me.

The emptiness was unsettling.

So was the relief.

Before leaving, Natalie said, “I don’t think you should simply believe me either.”

That surprised me.

“Then why tell me?”

“So you’ll start checking the stories you’ve been given.”

“What stories?”

“All of them.”

That evening, I drove to Carter’s brother’s house.

I didn’t go inside.

I texted Carter from the driveway.

ME: I’m outside. You don’t have to come out. I just need to give you something.

He appeared three minutes later in a dark jacket.

He looked exhausted.

“What happened?”

“Nothing.”

His eyes narrowed.

“That’s clearly not true.”

I held out a small envelope.

Inside was my key to the storage unit Logan and I had rented years earlier for camping equipment.

And a printed confirmation from the tattoo-removal clinic.

Carter looked at it.

“You scheduled this?”

“Yes.”

His gaze lifted.

“You don’t have to remove it for me.”

“I know.”

“Then why?”

“Because I don’t want it.”

He stared at me.

“For the first time, I know the difference.”

Something in his expression shifted.

I told him about Natalie.

Not every detail.

Enough.

He listened without interruption.

When I finished, he leaned against the porch railing.

“I’m sorry.”

I blinked.

“You’re sorry?”

“It sounds like you’re discovering that someone you trusted hasn’t always treated that trust carefully.”

I almost laughed through the pressure behind my eyes.

“You’re comforting me after I practically blew up our marriage.”

“Those things can both be true.”

Maya’s words returned.

Two people could fail you in different ways.

“Carter, I need to ask you something.”

“Okay.”

“If Logan disappeared tomorrow, would you come home?”

He thought carefully.

“No.”

The answer hurt.

But for once I didn’t argue with it.

“Why?”

“Because Logan isn’t the whole problem.”

“I am.”

“We are.”

He rubbed his hands against the cold.

“I don’t want a marriage where the only reason my needs matter is because we discovered Logan behaved badly.”

I nodded.

“You’re right.”

He looked surprised again.

“I keep saying that lately.”

“You almost never used to.”

“I know.”

A tiny smile appeared and vanished.

“I started seeing a counselor today.”

His eyebrows rose.

“Already?”

“I called this morning.”

“Why?”

“Because I don’t trust myself to know which parts of this are guilt and which parts are understanding.”

Carter looked at me for a long moment.

“That’s good.”

“Will you come with me sometime?”

“Maybe.”

Not yes.

But not no.

I accepted it.

As I turned toward my car, he called my name.

“Erin.”

I looked back.

“There’s something else about Union Station.”

My stomach tightened.

“What?”

“I didn’t tell you yesterday because I wasn’t sure it mattered.”

“What happened?”

“After Logan said you always choose him, he told me something about you.”

“What?”

Carter’s face was troubled.

“He said there was a reason you’d never completely let him go.”

I stared at him.

“What reason?”

“He said you made him a promise a long time ago.”

I searched my memory.

“What promise?”

“He wouldn’t tell me.”

A laugh escaped me, thin and nervous.

“Then maybe he was bluffing.”

“Maybe.”

But Carter didn’t sound convinced.

That night I went through old boxes.

Photos.

Birthday cards.

Concert tickets.

A shoebox filled with memories from my twenties.

At the bottom was a folded letter.

My handwriting covered the envelope.

FOR LOGAN — OPEN IF I EVER GET TOO SERIOUS ABOUT SOMEONE.

My heartbeat slowed.

I didn’t remember writing it.

I opened the envelope.

The letter was eleven years old.

The first paragraph was ridiculous.

Young.

Dramatic.

Then I reached the final lines.

No matter who we date, marry, or become, promise we never let anyone make us ordinary.

If either of us ever starts choosing some relationship over us, the other person has permission to remind them who they really are.

FWB forever.

My hands went cold.

The phrase wasn’t new.

The tattoo wasn’t an impulsive joke.

It had been born eleven years earlier.

Then something slipped from the envelope.

A second piece of paper.

Not mine.

Logan’s handwriting.

Undated.

One sentence.

Don’t worry, E. If you ever forget the promise, I’ll make sure you remember.

**–END OF PART 4–CLICK “”NEXT”” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**

✓ S. Gary Kenneth

## Part 4 – The Version I Was Given **Part 4** Natalie agreed to meet me the following afternoon. We chose a small café near Washington Park. Neutral ground. Public. Quiet. I arrived fifteen mi…

Leave a Reply